Friday, October 30, 2026

#BookReview: Beautiful prose isn't enough

 The Djinn Waits a Hundred Years, by Shubnum Khan (Viking)


I wanted to like this book. I really did, and for the first 20% or so, I enjoyed it. The setting – a mouldering old house in Durban, South Africa – the widow and his teenaged daughter, Sana, whose way of experiencing the world is as richly lyrical as it is unusual, the other inhabitants of the house. Add to that the mystery of what happened in the house and why it’s haunted by a festering, evil djinn, and all these elements carried the opening.

Alas, it’s a high wire act to use setting and character as the forward momentum of a novel, no matter how vivid they may be in their own right. This is not to say that a novel cannot be focused on character or setting, only that the energy driving the story must arise from them, catapulting events into dramatic tension. Otherwise, the story drifts from one interesting or amusing incident to the next, dissipating engagement and curiosity about what’s going on and why.

This was my experience, although of course, other readers may have a different take on this book. It was always about to get going and then sinking back into stasis. Things that might have been charming crotchets, like the humorous friction between the house’s inhabitants, turned into irritations when it seemed that was all there was to the story. I never could figure out why Sana had such an unusual way of experiencing the world because her semi-hallucinatory state never varied. Without question, the prose is beautiful, filled with offbeat connections and unusual ways of interpreting reality.

For me, as a reader, however, “lyrically stunning” can go only so far in overcoming “lack of story tension.” The book went from always-getting-started to drifting to slog, in which I found myself looking for something else to do besides reading it.

As usual, your mileage may vary.

No comments:

Post a Comment